photo4life
New Rocker Rollin'
Posts: 40
Favourite Quo Album: Blue For You
Favourite other bands.: Rush, Queen, Thin Lizzy, Genesis, Blue Öyster Cult
|
Post by photo4life on Jul 2, 2020 22:52:21 GMT
I haven't been posting here at all for many years, because I felt so alienated by the whole fan community, not just Quo but many bands in the last years. Rick's death made it easy for me to stay away, but I have gradually come back, and I hope I can contribute again.
This is my list from best to worst of all the 33 official SQ albums. Maybe I should explain a little why and how the list looks the way it does. Being born in the mid-70s I wasn't around when Quo made history, so when I got into them their best years were behind them. I was 12 when I got into Quo, even though I had been aware of them all my life (I recall loving both Whatever You Want and What You're Proposing as a little kid), and the catalyst was oddly enough In The Army Now and the song that made me go over the edge was Rollin' Home. Since then I have bought almost all of them, some exceptions (I'm NOT a loyal buyer who gets something for the sake of completing a collection!), and over the years this list has grown to the point where I can show it to the world, even if you don't want to see it.
I have been inspired by the YouTube channel and webzine Sea Of Tranquility to do this list. Their editor Pete Pardo has daily video rankings and deep cut dive videos as well, and many of my favourite bands have been on there. He has on two occasions said that Quo have too many albums to be ranked, maybe he will in the future.
Since Quo have been rather prolific the list is quite daunting and it wasn't easy putting it together, and some of the mid-list albums may be subject to change, but the top ten has stayed the same these last 10 years. Below the list I will tell you why they are where they are. Have fun, tell me what you think (why I'm right or wrong) and maybe you can add your own ranking as well Blue For you Quo Whatever You Want Just Supposin’ On The Level Rockin’ All Over The World Heavy Traffic Never Too Late Hello! Piledriver
If You Can’t Stand The Heat… In The Army Now Quid Pro Quo Backbone In Search Of The Fourth Chord Ain’t Complaining The Party Ain’t Over Yet Dog Of Two Head Ma Kelly’s Greasy Spoon Under The Influence
Rock ’til You Drop Spare Parts Riffs Bula Quo Back To Back Perfect Remedy 1+9+8+2 Thirsty Work Picturesque Matchstickable Messages From The Status Quo Don’t Stop
Famous In The Last Century Aquostic - Stripped Bare Aquostic 2 - That’s A Fact!
Starting from the bottom: The last 4 are subpar Quo, and would be subpar for many bands. They're even so bad that many of the artists out there I dislike could do better with these. Their debut has this low ranking to me because it sounds hurried and unfocused. TW has its moments but suffers from the lack of consistency in the material. The numbers album really is Quo by numbers. It sounds as if they wanted to make a pop album with rock hooks, but got stuck in limbo. It's saved somewhat by Resurrection, Doesn't Matter and I Should Have Known. Out of the slimy bottom we have we got Perfect Remedy and Back To Back. Albums that could have been much better if they had let go of the poppy elements of Back To Back and the country elements of Perfect Remedy. Bula Quo has its saving graces but feels like it was made as a joke. I haven't seen the film so I can't tell what role they play there. From Riffs and up we have albums that are pretty much good, and above anything most artists outside my main music taste could ever dream of making. Riffs isn't really an album for listening to individual tracks, the songs aren't that well made. Instead listening to it in full will make it a more enjoyable experience, but not too often. Same goes for Spare Parts, which is a fresh restart from their debut.
Rock 'til You Drop is very good but a bit too long, and I'm not talking about the wonderful new version of 4500 Times. No, there are too many songs. But good that they remade Tommy. It could have worked even back in the 70s with this arrangement. From Under The Influence to If You Can't Stand The Heat... what I can say is that they have dips, some of them really deep, but also high points that even surpass some of the songs made on my favourite albums.
On to the top ten. All of them have their own special story to them, and I feel so much for each of these. There are only lesser things that separate them in this order above. Quo has my overall favourite song, Backwater, but Fine, Fine, Fine and the fact that Alan sings a bit out of tune on Drifting Away makes it No 2 for me. What makes Blue For You my favourite album is that the songs are all so good and this is an album I can reach for and just listen to like that.
If you have read so far, thank you. I hope it makes for good reading if nothing else.
|
|
|
Post by dennis on Jul 2, 2020 23:06:51 GMT
Thanks for that. It's always fascinating to read a different perspective. However, I feel you may have run out of steam as you went on, seeing how little you wrote about your top 20 compared to your bottom 13. It'd be interesting if you could expand somewhat on those albums you rate more highly.
|
|
photo4life
New Rocker Rollin'
Posts: 40
Favourite Quo Album: Blue For You
Favourite other bands.: Rush, Queen, Thin Lizzy, Genesis, Blue Öyster Cult
|
Post by photo4life on Jul 2, 2020 23:11:32 GMT
Thanks for that. It's always fascinating to read a different perspective. However, I feel you may have run out of steam as you went on, seeing how little you wrote about your top 20 compared to your bottom 13. It'd be interesting if you could expand somewhat on those albums you rate more highly. I really did run out of steam, and forgot that I had rice cooking for lunch at work tomorrow .
I will post a more thorough look now
|
|
photo4life
New Rocker Rollin'
Posts: 40
Favourite Quo Album: Blue For You
Favourite other bands.: Rush, Queen, Thin Lizzy, Genesis, Blue Öyster Cult
|
Post by photo4life on Jul 3, 2020 0:31:29 GMT
Top twenty
If You Can’t Stand The Heat… In The Army Now Quid Pro Quo Backbone In Search Of The Fourth Chord Ain’t Complaining The Party Ain’t Over Yet Dog Of Two Head Ma Kelly’s Greasy Spoon Under The Influence
As I said earlier, the top 20 aren't flawless but most of them are above most other artists' albums in my opinion. I will try to do some quick things with all albums. Under The Influence isn't bad but the songs are uneven. Still miles above the albums around it. Ma Kelly's Greasy Spoon is a good album, half of it. This is where Quo are trying to find their way. The last song Gotta Go Home is a bit too long, maybe 1-2 minutes could shaved off and Daughter sounds misplaced.
Dog Of Two Head is at the point in my list where I can say with confidence that Quo weren't making anything wrong, unintentionally. Small mistakes are accepted and some songs aren't as good as the others, but this doesn't change much. The Party Ain't Over Yet is good and could have been great if Stupid Cupid, The Bubble and All That Counts Is Love were cut from it. They are B-side material, nothing else.
Ain't Complaining has made a trip down my list in the last 30 years. I adored it in the beginning, mostly because I didn't know a lot about them back then, and I have a soft spot for 80s productions and songs. The reason it has gone down is that I have heard better albums, that's all. I still think most of the songs are good, but not as good as the songs on the albums I rank above it. Also, I Know You're Leaving and Who Gets The Love aren't good enough for the album.
In Search Of The Fourth Chord and Backbone are two good albums that I feel are overlooked. They aren't similar at all, the former is hard, very tough where the latter is more upbeat, I must say that Backbone is Back To Back if it got better treatment. If all songs were like Backing Off it would have been much higher.
Quid Pro Quo is an album I often forget about for some reason, but everytime I remind myself of it I am surprised of its qualities. One song too many and the remake of In The Army Now is pointless, otherwise very, very good. In The Army Now is the album that got me into Quo, as I have said before, and it still has a special place for me. Maybe I have a bit of a thing for it, but I can only see Invitationa and Dreamin' as the songs that should have been cut from it. Maybe Lonely and Heartburn could have been there instead. If You Can't Stand The Heat... is an album that also have made a trip down the list. I really, really liked it but when I looked at it with more critical eyes I found that the two Rossi tracks on side one were the weaker ones. They're not cut away-worthy, but not as good as the rest of them.
Top ten
Blue For you Quo Whatever You Want Just Supposin’ On The Level Rockin’ All Over The World Heavy Traffic Never Too Late Hello! Piledriver
My top ten is written in stone since about 2010, and they're pretty much flawless to me, with slight differences putting them where they are. Piledriver, I remember thinking A Year was a mistake the first time I listened to the album, but the more I listen to it the more I like it. Still I am affeted by my knee jerk reaction. Maybe a psychological thing here. Hello! is number 9 because of the dough-like production. Yes, the whole album sounds like a dough. A great dough, for making cinnamon buns, but still rather odd sound to me. Since I'm not a professional musician I don't know the terminology but the album, with Caroline, Blue-Eyed Lady and Softer Ride as exceptions, sounds subdued. The album is fantastic, it's the dough sound that makes it great. Never Too Late, if the albums were wines, this would be a nice rare one from the back of the racks, the one you take out to show your friends how good it is to have a hidden gem with so many good flavours. It's the kind of album you can play in the background and often people will say: "This is good. Who are they?", and they will be surprised when you tell them. Heavy Traffic is the latest addition to the top ten, and their best in almost 40 years. Even the "worst" song, Digging Burt Bacharach is great. A little more beef in the boogie section of the song and it would be really great. On The Level. Just Supposin' and Whatever You Want are where they are because they are so hard to tell apart from each other, in my opinion. They're so good that I have to go into nitpicking to tell them apart. On The Level has that annoying audience chant at the end. Why? Just Supposin' has Rock'n'roll which is good ballad, but a bit repetitive. Whatever You Want doesn't have the full version of High Flyer. They could have added those extra 25 seconds easily.
Quo and Blue For You aren't perfect, but no album is. There will always be smaller things to, again, nitpick on. Hope I have made my opinion clear, and I would love to see how it differs from your opinions.
|
|
|
Post by vivfromcov on Jul 3, 2020 0:34:56 GMT
Very interesting to read your thoughts! It’s a lot of work to write it all though! Don’t think I’ll be able to do anything similar. But if I do, it will not cover all of their albums as I didn’t get Army or any after until 4th chord.
|
|
mortified
4500 Timer
Posts: 5,835
Favourite Quo Album: Hello!
Favourite other bands.: Talking Heads, Rolling Stones, Sheryl Crow, Gary Numan, Alabama 3, ZZ Top, Paul van Dyk, Jeff Beck, Bowie, Gerry Rafferty, Band of Skulls, UFO, S.A.H.B
|
Post by mortified on Jul 3, 2020 6:08:01 GMT
If I tried this, I'd be here for weeks Nice to share your thoughts though. We'd all have them in a different order; every one of us. And you're right; when you first hear something (i.e. at what age) it has a strange impact on your perception of it further down the line. I think I'd probably have 7 of your top 10 in mine. And 8 of your bottom 13 would also match what I'd have. I guess that leaves 8 on which we'd fundamentally disagree. But it's a subjective exercise. There are no rights or wrongs; just opinions and taste. I suspect many might have Quo Live as their no.1 but you have only considered studio albums, which I think is reasonable given the proliferation of so many live releases, especially in the last 12 years. And, of course, their sheer similarity. But you did say that you haven't collected everything. Perhaps wisely. I'm not wise.
|
|
|
Post by charles on Jul 3, 2020 7:25:09 GMT
I know I'm being predictable, but surely Dog and Kell's deserve a spot in the top ten? I got to know them through a German double compilation album and those songs were so much more interesting than the hits I already got tired of (think Caroline). Is it really me/ Gotta Go Home is probably my number two song, right behind 4500 times.
|
|
|
Post by fretbuzzzzz on Jul 3, 2020 8:15:37 GMT
Anyone who can liken sounds and production of albums to dough and cinnamon buns and get that into a review is probably worthy of us taking the time to read through their literary works!
As mortified has said, it's a subjective exercise and most of us will agree and disagree in varying degrees, but 10/10 for effort.
Agree that it can be interesting to play the lesser known Quo album tracks, but ones that are often held in high regard by the Quo cognoscenti, to unsuspecting acquaintances, who in turn are then impressed by what they are hearing and they didn't see that coming!
|
|
|
Post by charles on Jul 3, 2020 8:48:02 GMT
Gerdundula is a prime example of a Quo song that everybody loves, the missus included. They also never fail to mention it doesn't sound like Quo.
|
|
mortified
4500 Timer
Posts: 5,835
Favourite Quo Album: Hello!
Favourite other bands.: Talking Heads, Rolling Stones, Sheryl Crow, Gary Numan, Alabama 3, ZZ Top, Paul van Dyk, Jeff Beck, Bowie, Gerry Rafferty, Band of Skulls, UFO, S.A.H.B
|
Post by mortified on Jul 3, 2020 9:29:57 GMT
Anyone who can liken sounds and production of albums to dough and cinnamon buns and get that into a review is probably worthy of us taking the time to read through their literary works!
As mortified has said, it's a subjective exercise and most of us will agree and disagree in varying degrees, but 10/10 for effort. Agree that it can be interesting to play the lesser known Quo album tracks, but ones that are often held in high regard by the Quo cognoscenti, to unsuspecting acquaintances, who in turn are then impressed by what they are hearing and they didn't see that coming! Ditto with anyone who can get the word "cognoscenti" into a post!
|
|
|
Post by railroad007 on Jul 3, 2020 10:07:49 GMT
I think that Piledriver is such a great album that if they had released this and then gone away it would have been enough for me. 37 minutes, that's been all I've needed. Some of the other albums are superb but this is the best thing they ever did.
|
|
|
Post by Victor on Jul 3, 2020 10:09:02 GMT
Never too late Hello Dog of Two Head / Ma Kelly's Greasy Spoon Quo On the level/Whatever you want Piledriver/Blue for you Just Supposin Under the Influence/QPQ Backbone/1982
Rocking all over the world/If you can't stand the heat Rock 'till you drop The Party ain't over yet In search of the Fourth Chord Heavy Traffic In the Army now Thirsty Work
Ain't complaining Picturesque Spare parts Perfect Remedy Riffs Famous in the last Centurey Back to back Don't stop Bula Quo/Aquostic 1 and 2
|
|
|
Post by dennis on Jul 3, 2020 13:22:30 GMT
I'm so glad you completed the exercise, photo4life, your views of those albums you rate more highly are very interesting.
I'm very much a '70s Quo fan, & largely the same for most everything else! My Quo collection peters out after '81, apart from some subsequent live material pre-Live Aid & then some more from the Reunions.
One point that caught my eye was your comment: "... I Know You're Leaving and Who Gets The Love aren't good enough for the album." Funnily enough, I thought they were the best two tracks on that particular album. Just goes to show how subjective these things are.
|
|
|
Post by railroad007 on Jul 3, 2020 13:41:39 GMT
The bit at 2:37 into the solo, that was it, right there....2 seconds and that was all. It actually swaggers into the solo. No one ever does that.
|
|
|
Post by dennis on Jul 3, 2020 14:09:47 GMT
I think that Piledriver is such a great album that if they had released this and then gone away it would have been enough for me. 37 minutes, that's been all I've needed. Some of the other albums are superb but this is the best thing they ever did. Absotively! My favourite of them all. If forced to find fault with the album then the only criticism I'd make is that the shouldn't have left Softer Ride off. Although, I appreciate some people would knock a mark off for the inclusion of a cover song but it is quite an iconic cover for Quo.
|
|